Emerging trade models can work for the poultry sector, but the industry must play its part in developing them.
Today’s geopolitics are revealing the limits of the multinational trade model we have grown used to. This is not necessarily a bad thing, particularly if taken as an opportunity to improve the current model, or to build a new system that better fits our needs.
We have learned to live with the system’s limits, for example how slow and ineffective it can be, but, at the same time, we must acknowledge it has allowed the global economy to grow and international trade to become easier.
The World Trade Organization (WTO) stands as the perfect example of this dichotomy. Since it was created in 1995, evolving from the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), its founding principle, that all trading partners would be treated equally under the Most Favored Nation rule, has been a key contributor to the trade environment.
However, the devil is in the details. The implementation of the principle has been difficult and subject to several, probably too many, exceptions. There is also the far-from-conclusive dispute settlement mechanism. This, on occasion, has been swamped, including with disputes relating to our industry. Nevertheless, the overarching framework — the shared idea that market access should be predictable, while disputes should be resolved through law rather than leverage, has strongly influenced several business models, poultry meat included.
What we are now experiencing, in addition to energy shocks and inflation, is the understanding that the very foundations of that business model are being challenged, if not already abandoned. Within the poultry meat supply chain, optimized over decades for efficiency, resilience is the new guiding star for success. International rules on market access, investment and trade, alternately resorted to by all, are increasingly worth less than guidelines.
Ways forward
How can our industry, with the most globally traded meat, adapt its business model to a new era in which multilateralism is replaced by regional and national prioritization? There is no magic formula, but there are steps that can be taken to mitigate the impact of current uncertainties.
The first is diversification, both upstream and downstream in the value chain, from markets to suppliers and political relationships. The closure of the Strait of Hormuz has shown how an excessive level of dependence is no longer acceptable. Our sector should treat market diversification not simply as a commercial aspiration but as a risk management necessity.
Second is to frame the industry’s value proposition and align it to the growing market autonomy approach. Food sovereignty and trade are not necessarily contradictory. Trade plays a role in food security by providing products that may not otherwise be available. Our industry must position itself as a strategic partner rather than a mere commodity supplier.
Third is to invest in diplomacy and relationship building. In an unstable and evolving environment, the private sector must invest in bilateral relationships and regional partnerships that can survive as the multilateral order fragments.
New regional trade agreements, which may be imperfect and asymmetric, yet functional, represent a viable trade architecture for the foreseeable future. Our sector needs to be present, vocal and technically credible in the rooms where these new frameworks are being shaped.
The WTO era may be ending, but trade will take us into the new era. Poultry is, and will continue to be, the most-globally-traded meat for years to come, and any new system must allow flows that facilitate food security and geographic balance. Our sector must focus on the role we want to play in building this new system, and how quickly we can adapt to the new environment.